Ask four questions before you use it. Did it work from code text I gave it, or from memory? Are these my inputs? Would I accept every assumption? Did it add anything I didn't ask for?
Four questions to ask every AI answer
An answer can read well and still rest on a clause the AI misremembered or an assumption you never made.
- 1Did it work from code text I gave it, or from memory?
- 2Are these the inputs I gave it?
- 3Would I accept every assumption it made?
- 4Did it add anything I didn't ask for?
AI can help you set up, explain and draft. The checking, the review and the design itself stay with you.
Wrong defaults are easy to miss
Wrong defaults are easy to miss, such as a site in the wrong city or a species you don't use. Run the key number through a calculator you can see.
Here is the lesson 1 prompt again, then an answer to it. Compare them line by line.
The lesson 1 prompt
I'm checking a residential floor joist to NDS 2018. Span 14 ft, joists at 16 in. centers, live load 40 psf, dead load 10 psf, Douglas fir-larch No. 2. List the checks I need to run, the inputs each check depends on, and every assumption you're making. Don't calculate the final numbers.
Checks to run: bending, shear, deflection and bearing.
Inputs: 14 ft span, joists at 16 in. centers, 40 psf live, 10 psf dead.
Assumptions: normal load duration, dry service, Southern pine No. 2, top edge braced by the subfloor.
Can you spot the wrong default? Show the answer
The species. The prompt named Douglas fir-larch No. 2, and the answer assumed Southern pine No. 2. Every other input matches, which is what makes it easy to miss.
Checking the lesson 1 joist answer
- Did it list every check you expected (bending, shear, deflection, bearing, vibration)?
- Are its assumptions ones you would accept, such as load duration, moisture condition and lateral restraint?
- Does any clause it cites exist in the edition you named, and say what it claims?
Try it
Take the answer you got from your lesson 1 prompt, and run it through the four questions.
Last reviewed:
